Skip to main content
General

Classic Creamy Mashed Potatoes

By November 18, 2025November 18th, 2026No Comments

For as long as I can remember, if mashed potatoes are on the holiday menu, I have been the one charged with making them. I don’t mind this at all because among other things it confers great power upon me — “Don’t forget to make twice the amount of mashed potatoes as you think we need, then triple that,” my daughter once told me. It’s a great honor to be trusted with something so important, but it recently occurred to me that I’ve never recorded the wisdom I’ve accrued from decades of world-class mashing. Herewith, my recipe, plus mix-in suggestions and make-ahead instructions if that’s your thing.

Reminder: All the fun stuff is happening on Substack. Please join the party!

Classic Creamy Mashed Potatoes with Horseradish & Parm
(Or Desired Mix-in)

When I’m making mashed potatoes for a small crew, I favor using a ricer, which results in the smoothest texture. But when I’m dealing with large amounts, like on Thanksgiving, I use either an electric mixer or a potato masher for ease. My preferred mix-ins are prepared horseradish and Parm, but choose your own adventure from the list below. This recipe serves 8-10.

4 pounds potatoes (baking/Russet or Yukon Gold), peeled and sliced in thirds if Russet, and in halves if Yukon Golds
1 tablespoon kosher salt, plus more to taste
6 tablespoons unsalted butter
1 1/2 cups whole milk or half-and-half, warmed in a saucepan or a microwave
your mix-in of choice (see options above photo)
My preferred mix-ins: 3 tablespoons prepared horseradish, 1 cup freshly grated Parmesan

In a large pot, cover the potatoes with water, add salt, and bring to a boil. Reduce the heat to a simmer and cook until a knife can slip through the biggest chunk of potato with zero resistance. It usually takes between 15 and 20 minutes, but you can err on the side of over-doing it because they’ll only get softer and more mash-able. Drain in a colander, and return the empty pot to the stove.

Add the potatoes, more salt to taste, butter, and about half of the milk to the pot and, using a potato masher (or an electric hand mixer), start whipping the potatoes until smooth, slowly adding the rest of the warm milk until you reach desired (creamy, smooth) consistency.

Stir in desired mix-ins and serve warm.

Mix-in Options

When it comes to mix-ins, I always go with horseradish and Parm, but I wrote about other options in a 2023 Cup of Jo column and of course readers weighed in with many more excellent ideas, so please head over there for more inspiration. (V = good options for vegans)

* 2 tablespoons prepared horseradish (V)
* 1 cup freshly grated Parmigiano-Reggiano
* 1 cup grated sharp cheddar
* 1 caramelized onion (V, 1 large sliced onion cooked slowly in olive oil over low heat for 30 minutes until the onions get sweet and golden)
* 3/4 cup sour cream
*1/2 cup snipped chives (v)
* 4 to 5 ounces cream cheese
* Roasted garlic (V)
* Nutritional yeast (V)
* Extra butter and cream — similar to scrambled eggs, the more fat you add, the more luscious they will taste
* olive oil (V)
* vegetable broth (V), I prefer Whole Foods’ 365 brand broth

Good combos: Horseradish & Parm; Sour Cream & Chives; Olive oil, Veg Broth, & Caramelized Onions; Cheddar & Chives

Make-Ahead Instructions to Ensure Piping-Hot Potatoes

As a way to avoid super fussy cooking during Holiday Dinner Crunch Time, I’ve often made my mashed potatoes the day before, then reheated in a baking dish covered with foil, casserole-style, an hour before the big meal. But they always seemed to fall short — a shade too dry and never piping hot the way the best mashed potatoes should be. Last year, though, I finally cracked the case using two strategies:

  1. I made them early in the morning on feast day, which meant they never had to hang out in the refrigerator overnight getting chilled-to-the-bone cold. They were at room temperature when I slid them into the 300°F oven, which assured they’d be melt-the-butter hot all the way through an hour later.
  2. Next, before I reheated and covered with foil, I tossed the potatoes with about a half cup of warm whole milk (you can also use cream) which prevented them from drying out in the oven.

Now that’s what a Thanksgiving plate should look like.

Leave a Reply

What is 13 + 13 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)