Shrimp with Feta

 

I realize there is a whole segment of the American population that is going to be instantly turned off by the title of this post. Seafood and cheese — that’s just…wrong. But this recipe might just change your mind, as it did for me the first time my friend Melissa made it for us about a decade ago. Melissa, co-author of  The New Brooklyn Cookbook, was one of my first kitchen heroes — one of those friends who would serve me something that I would then pass off as my own to the next dozen dinner guests I cooked it for. (Oh, this? Just something I came across.) We’ve served it to bosses and in-laws, neighbors and siblings. And, of course, to our children — even when it meant cleaning the sauce off a few pieces of shrimp before serving.

[Photos updated December 2023]

Shrimp with Feta

2-3 garlic cloves, minced
3 tablespoons olive oil
1 28-ounce can whole peeled tomatoes (drained, very important)
1 pound shrimp, peeled and cleaned
Two-ish handfuls crumbled feta (you want some in every bite)
juice from half a lemon
salt and pepper to taste
chopped fresh parsley)

Preheat oven to 425°F. Sauté garlic in olive oil in an ovenproof skillet set over medium heat. Add tomatoes, and stir, breaking up with a wooden spoon or kitchen scissors. Lower heat to medium-low and cook for 10 minutes, letting the garlic infuse the tomatoes.

Nestle in the shrimp and cook until shrimp starts to turn pink all over, about 3 minutes, then sprinkle feta all over the top. Bake five minutes until cheese is melty and slightly golden.

Remove from the oven, drizzle lemon juice all over. Add salt and pepper to taste and garnish with parsley.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What is 5 + 2 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)

19 Comments

papa doc

I know an old Sicilian lady from Virginia who claims to have come up with this idea

2
Reply
Kate

I made this last night, and it was delicious. I’m definitely adding this to the rotation, thanks for the recipe!!

Reply
Trish O

There is a very similar recipe in “the Food You Crave” cookbook. It is the most wonderful thing. No lemon in hers. I like that idea and will be trying this version tonight.

PS, I am new to this blog and I LOVE it. Just made the pea dip yesterday and my 5 year old is addicted. I also miss Cookie so so so much.

1
Reply
Blair

Making this now, it looks and smells wonderful. Paired with Macrina bread from Seattle, cheese and a ginger beer martini. Happy Friday! and thanks for the inspiration.

2
Reply
Laura

I am SO making this! Luckily both my boys love shrimp and feta cheese. You have the best recipes, Thank you!

2
Reply
Brianna

Picked up your book today, this was the first recipe that caught my eye. Family LOVED it!!

2
Reply
Kathryn

I am making this ALL the time lately. I either add a handful of sliced kalamata olives or serve it with olive bread. Can’t lose!

Reply
Jennifer

Wow. Just saw your website for the first time yesterday. Saw this recipe and thought, hmmm, we have shrimp in the freezer, tomatoes in the closet, and I think we even have feta in the frig! Went home excited to make the dish. Husband and I gobbled it up, Delicious and simple (and attractive, even). Low calorie, low glycemic index, fast, ymmy…Yup! Definitely will be in our rotation. THANK YOU! I will bookmark your site – so excited to find more great info and recipes to try!

2
Reply
Jessie

This was my first attempt to make one of your recipes. I made this shrimp scampi last night, and it was SO GOOD. We ate every bite. I will definitely be making this again and adding it to the rotation. I am now obsessed with your blog, and I can’t wait to try more recipes! Thanks!

2
Reply
Stephanie

I’ve made this three times now for just me and my husband after the kids are in bed. Each time I pull up the recipe here I get such comfort out of the visual of how few ingredients there are. Didn’t have fresh parsley last night but it was just as delicious. The lemon is a stand-in for that bright flavor and we almost always have one lemon languishing in the fridge. We keep it free of any bread or noodles but no one minds getting a spoon out when it’s brothy. Great meal!

1
Reply
Maria Anagnostopoulou

its best to cook it in a clay pot or several little clay pots. It tastes better! Its the Greek way!lovely blog, I just discovered it!

1
Reply