Small-Scale Thanksgiving, Stock, Nutella-Berry Muffins

Good morning! I just listened to Samin & Hrishikesh’s Thanksgiving podcast on my walk to get coffee, and realized that I’m officially excited about the holiday — the cooking part at least. With one kid returning from college in the Midwest, the actual sit-down feast is not going to happen — at least not how we are used to seeing it. But, as Samin said, it’s a different year and we need to be OK that Thanksgiving looks a little different too. As much as we all crave this holiday — it’s almost primal for me at this point — I just have to accept it. The good news is that there’s no shortage of ideas for how to make a small-scale Thanksgiving feel special anyway. There are tons of ideas from readers on the DALS facebook page today, and also, there’s this Turkey Pot Pie I worked on for Cup of Jo that was requested by a reader. “Why not put the whole meal into one tasty pie?” She asked. Indeed! Why not?

Pot pie, as many of you probably know, is something we regularly make on, say, a Tuesday. So the challenge for me became: How do I make it special enough for Thanksgiving? The answer: Upgrade every ingredient possible. Pick up the freshest carrots and potatoes you can find and definitely try to track down all-butter puff pastry, such as Dufour brand. (The puff pastry itself is considerably more dramatic than the regular pie dough I usually use.) Lastly, if you can swing it…

Project: Homemade Stock

….try to use homemade stock. That’s one thing that hasn’t changed this year: I always make it a week or two before Thanksgiving, because it upgrades everything on the table — the gravy, the potatoes, the stuffing and it keeps in the freezer for three months, so even if I don’t use it next week, I know I’ll be very appreciative it’s there for future batches of polenta, soups, and risotto. Here’s the how-to: Place the bones of a roast chicken or turkey into a large soup pot along with a few carrots (cut into large pieces) a few celery stalks (chopped), a large quartered onion (any color), 8 to 10 sprigs of thyme or parsley, and a Parmesan rind if you have it. Add a generous amount of salt and about a teaspoon of black peppercorns. Cover everything with water and bring to a boil. Lower heat and simmer on the stove for at least one hour, and preferably as many as three or four. (You can also do this in a slow cooker overnight, but I remain convinced the stock has the hint of strangeness to it, when I do this.)

Project: Strawberry-Nutella Muffins

In other news, who knows why, but Abby came down to the kitchen last Sunday and declared she was in the mood for strawberry-nutella muffins and promptly whipped up a batch. They were delicious — definitely not light, but delicious. (PS: The platter from Revol, since everyone always asks me.) There’s nothing quite like a Sunday morning that smells like fresh baked goods.

Stay safe! Wear a mask!

The goal of the Project, Pantry, Purpose series to keep us sane, distracted, connected, and USEFUL. It began in March 2020. Please continue to comment below with suggestions for recipes, projects (for kids and adults), good deeds, donation ideas, stories, movies, games, puzzles. Or just tell me how you’re doing, what your story is, and especially how DALS might be able to help you or people in your community. You can also email me directly at

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Filed under: Thanksgiving

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What is 10 + 13 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)


Allie Alperovich

Thank you – I agree with the crock pot weirdness – I always want to use the crockpot for stock, beans, etc, but it never tastes as good? Any theories? My thinking is squash soup, turkey thighs/legs, and all of the yummy traditional sides.


Your Thanksgiving pie is reminiscent of a sacred weekly recipe in my house: The Monday Pie…

I’m British so a Sunday Roast is a common weekend occurrence during the winter months (usually a roast chicken) – we love the meal itself obviously but the best bit is the leftover pie that comes the next day. We always cook a bit extra of everything and when the meal is done and everyone is sitting at the table too stuffed to move, fill a pie dish with a little chicken, some roast potatoes, some ripped up yorkshire puddings, some stuffing and whatever vegetables we had alongside the roast. Stick it in the fridge overnight with leftover gravy kept in a separate jug.

Then the next day when you’re on you’re way home from work, the day has been long, everything has been very monday-ish…but you know that when you get home all you have to do is take that pie dish out the fridge, pour over the gravy, roll on a puff-pastry lid (definitely shop-bought and pre-rolled…its monday night), egg wash and cook for 25 mins. And then…oh my goodness the most delicious dinner, and one that takes youo through a portal back to the relaxed weekend version of yourself and perks up a rainy Monday night no end.

I’m sure your Thanksgiving pie will be even more delicious!


If instagram is to be believed, i was making stock at the same time you were! This year is going to be a bit of a bummer with the table set for just the three of us in my family. But i’m going to cook up the whole spread anyway because it’s how i operate. And i’ve arranged for a pre-meal meet-up with a few girlfriends, masked up and outside in a public park, where we will toast the strangeness of 2020 and be glad that the end is in sight. whew!


Do you cover the pot when making stock? Just to bring it to a boil? Or the whole time or the point to reduce it?


bring to a boil, then reduce to a simmer — do not cover. You can keep adding water if you want. Or you can reduce it for a richer, more concentrated stock.

Stephanie Olson

The upside down table cloth in the first photo makes me smirk. Looks like something I would do.


I love the Homecooking podcast and this week’s Thanksgiving episode was the best all year. Tracey Clayton on cornbread had me laughing in my kitchen.

Alison Coleman

Thank you for sharing Samin & Hrishikesh’s podcast! I LOVE listening to podcasts while I’m cooking (which is a LOT lately!) and this one is perfect! They have such wonderful chemistry!